Contact Us Today 216-771-2600

Defective Workmanship Does Not Constitute “an Occurrence” Under A Contractor’s Liability Insurance

Last month, the Ohio Supreme Court answered a question certified to it by the US Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals regarding contractor liability insurance. The question posed: Whether a claim for defective construction or workmanship constitutes a “property damage occurrence” under a commercial general liability insurance policy. The answer: it does not, defects are not accidents.

Why does this matter for Associations? When the Board hires a contractor to complete a task, usually the Board requests to see a copy of the liability insurance. While this liability insurance may cover things such as a ladder going through a window, a tree cutting gone wrong that falls on a roof, or a worker being injured on the job, this general liability insurance will NOT cover defective workmanship (i.e. the roof leaks 6 months after replacement, a retaining wall fails 2 years later). If the Board decides to sue for a defect, the general policy will provide no relief at all. So make sure there is a specific provision for defects in workmanship or defects in the insurance policy. Westfield Ins. Co. v. Custom Agri Sys., Inc., Slip Opinion No. 2012-Ohio-4712

More on Real Estate Law

The Attorneys at Ott & Associates Co., LPA, frequently write and publish legal articles in order to educate clients on continuously changing laws in each practice area.

Beware of Lender Questionnaires

Sharing Email Accounts

As your legal counsel, we become part of your team, providing the legal component to your business decisions.

Let us get started today.


Ott & Associates Co., LPA

1300 E 9th St, Suite 1520
Cleveland, OH 44114

Ph: 216-771-2600
Fx: 216-830-8939


©2024 Ott & Associates Co., LPA All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy